Mark: Treading Water

Sermon by Derek Thomas on September 29, 2004

Mark 6:45-46

Wednesday Evening

September 29, 2004

Mark 6:45-46

“Treading Water”

Dr. Derek W. H. Thomas

Now turn with me, if you would, to the Gospel of Mark, and
we pick up again where we left off last Wednesday evening, in Mark 6, beginning
at verse 45–the section that is very familiar, of Jesus’ walking on the water.
You’ll remember that last week we were looking together at the story of the
feeding of the five thousand. The disciples had made their way to the northeast
section of the Sea of Galilee. Crowds had watched the little boat as it had made
its way across, and followed along the shoreline. And towards the end of that
afternoon, Jesus feeds them through…His disciples feed them…this great
multitude. And we left off as verse 44: “And those who ate the loaves were five
thousand men.”

Before we read the passage together, let’s come
before God in prayer. Let’s pray.

Our gracious God and ever blessed Father, we
thank You for Your word; that no prophecy of Scripture comes by private
interpretation, but men moved by the Holy Spirit–driven, carried along by the
Holy Spirit–spoke. And we thank You for this written Scripture, this
infallible, inerrant word of truth that lies before us this evening. We ask for
Your blessing. Come, Holy Spirit, grant us light, illumination, insight into
Your word for Jesus’ sake. Amen.

Hear with me the word of God.

“And immediately He made His disciples get into the boat and go ahead of Him to
the other side to Bethsaida, while He Himself was sending the multitude away.
And after bidding them farewell, He departed to the mountain to pray. And when
it was evening, the boat was in the midst of the sea, and He was alone on the
land. And seeing them straining at the oars, for the wind was against them, at
about the fourth watch of the night, He came to them, walking on the sea; and He
intended to pass by them. But when they saw Him walking on the sea, they
supposed that it was a ghost, and cried out; for they all saw Him and were
frightened. But immediately He spoke with them and said to them, “Take courage;
it is I, do not be afraid.” And He got into the boat with them, and the wind
stopped; and they were greatly astonished, for they had not gained any insight
from the incident of the loaves, but their heart was hardened. And when they
had crossed over they came to land at Gennesaret, and moored to the shore. And
when they had come out of the boat, immediately the people recognized Him, and
ran about that whole country and began to carry about on their pallets those who
were sick, to the place they heard He was. And wherever he entered villages, or
cities, or countryside, they were laying the sick in the market places, and
entreating Him that they might just touch the fringe of His cloak; and as many
as touched it were being cured.”

Amen. May God add His blessing to the reading of his holy
and inerrant word.

I sat in a seminary class thirty years ago. It was
a seminary that I attended for two years or so, a liberal Presbyterian seminary,
now faculty-adjunct status of the University of Wales. And it was a Greek
class; we were translating the Gospel of Mark. And I remember we were in this
passage, Jesus walking on the Sea of Galilee. And I recall it being pointed out
to me, something of the various nuances of Mark’s Greek style. But what I
remember most is the ridicule that I was subjected to because I made it clear in
a fairly naпve sort of fashion, as I recall, that I actually believed this story
to be true: that Jesus actually did walk on the Sea of Galilee.

You see, for about two hundred years or so now,
since the time of The Enlightenment, Emanuel Kant and Jean Jacques Rousseau, and
Jefferson, in your own country here, folk have denied that things like this
happened. The results of empirical science of Newtonian physics tell us that
gravity, heavier bodies coming into contact with water–surface tension
notwithstanding–implies that these sort of things just don’t happen. And it’s
true that you and I, whilst we may have seen a fly or some insect walk, due to
surface tension, on the surface of the water, we’ve never seen a human being
walk on anything like the Sea of Galilee.

And then, along came Albert Schweitzer. Some of you
may have had the misfortune of coming across Albert Schweitzer–not in the flesh,
you understand–but in one of his books, and especially the most famous of his
books, The Quest for the Historical Jesus, in which he systematically
removes from the Scriptures all references to the miraculous, and to the
supernatural; claiming that what actually happened here in this narrative is
what happens to all fishing and lake stories: they become exaggerated. And what
the disciples probably saw was Jesus walking either on a sand bank, or walking
on the edge of the Sea of Galilee, and they concluded–or at least the story
is…it got told and retold–became Jesus’ walking closer and closer to them on
the actual Sea of Galilee itself.

I remember thirty years ago reading a book, and I’ve
not looked at it since, by a very eminent scholar of the twentieth century, a
Dr. Vincent Taylor, the guru of New Testament theology in the Methodist church,
probably the leading theologian and biblical critic in the Methodist church in
the twentieth century. His commentary on the synoptic gospels, his commentary
on Mark’s gospel, caused an enormous stir. It was much sought after and read.
And what did the eminent Vincent Taylor say about this story? That what happened
was that they saw, wading through the surf, near the hidden shore, Jesus. And
this was interpreted as a triumphant progress across the waters. It sounds like
a Californian life-saver, according to Vincent Taylor.

Well, I tell you that because some of you were
raised in churches that reinterpreted the miracles of the Bible along that way.
Some of you have heard such interpretations perhaps in school or college.
Anyway, I expressed then in a seminary classroom, as a physics major, you
understand, at university, that I actually believed that Jesus not only could,
but actually did walk on the surface of the Sea of Galilee. And you know, my
friends, if you believe that Jesus is the Creator of the universe, last night’s
Nova four-hour special notwithstanding for those of you who might have
seen that thing last night on public television about the origin of the
universe, if we really believe that Jesus created the universe, where’s the
problem here? Can I say it? This is a trifling little thing. I mean, really!
This is a trifling little thing for the Creator of the universe to walk on the
Sea of Galilee!

Now, let’s get to the scene, because Jesus dismisses
the disciples. The five thousand, maybe ten thousand–five thousand men, it
says–have been fed. And now Jesus sends the disciples away. It’s a somewhat
strange thing. He puts them into the boat. The Greek is very strong: He made
them get into the boat. You have this picture of Jesus saying to the disciples,
sort of hustling them into the boat on the edge of the Sea of Galilee, and
saying, ‘Go!’; and perhaps some of them protesting and saying, ‘But, Master, we
prefer to stay with You!’ And Jesus is saying, ‘No, go! Go to the other side.
I’ll join you later.’

Now, the explanation for that most commonly given is
that amongst this great crowd, these thousands of people on the shore, were all
kinds of messianic views and expectations. And it’s obvious from the story
itself that the disciples are not clear who Jesus is. The disciples don’t
recognize Him at first when He walks, thinking perhaps they’ve seen a ghost.
And perhaps in order to protect them from the hysteria of this crowd, He bids
the disciples leave in a boat and go to the other side of the Sea of Galilee
while He himself dismisses this crowd. Well, I want us to see three things
from the passage tonight.

I. The first thing is this: that
the disciples find themselves in trouble.

They find themselves in trouble. They find
themselves in what the other gospels describe as a storm, a tropical storm.
Tonight we can imagine something of what they find themselves in. The Sea of
Galilee is six hundred feet below sea level. And it’s two thousand feet below
the surrounding hills and Mt. Hermon especially, way up to the northeast. And
at night, when the temperature cools, that cold air can come quickly down the
side of that mountain and cause what’s called a squall, or a storm, and it
actually has a name: the searah, the storm on the Sea of Galilee, and it
was greatly feared, even by some experienced fishermen on the Sea of Galilee.

Now, a couple of things here: notice how
suddenly they find themselves in trouble
. You know, a few hours earlier
they were witnessing one of the most astonishing things they’d seen in their
entire lives–that as Jesus (as perhaps this is how it happened), that as He
handed to them these loaves and these fishes, it kept on coming. It kept on
multiplying. They had witnessed with their own eyes, handled with their own
hands, an astonishing miracle of our Lord. They were in the seventh heaven.
They were near to Jesus; they were seeing the kingdom of God advancing. They
were seeing the presence of the divine Messiah in their very midst. You can
imagine how excited they must have been. And within hours they find themselves
in trouble. Just like you can be in a church service and surrounded by
Christian friends and brothers, and the word of God is coming home to you and
encouraging you, and challenging you, motivating you. And you’re thrilled by
that, captivated by it, and drawn into the presence of Jesus! And you go home
and you’re thinking about it all the way home, and then you open the front door
and….bang. And you descend into reality once again, and there’s a storm, and
there’s a problem, and there are difficulties, and there are tensions, and there
are quarrels, and there are arguments. How quickly we can find ourselves moving
from a period of blessing to a period of trouble.

But they’re not just that, but they’re in
trouble–and note this–they’re in trouble because they did what Jesus told them
to do
. Now you might understand…we might expect, from one point of
view, that trouble would come when you disobeyed Jesus. When Jonah finds himself
in a storm in a boat on the sea, we’re told it was a consequence of his
rebellion. God was catching up with him. We might expect that. But you see
what’s being taught here: through no fault of their own…actually the very
opposite, an act of obedience on their part to the very commandment of Jesus,
they find themselves in trouble. They find themselves in difficulty. They’d
done everything right, and they still end up in trouble. You follow Jesus, you
pray to Him, to express your love and adoration for Him, and still you get into

It’s the fourth watch of the night, somewhere
between four and six in the morning. They’d been on this lake for a long time.
It was probably still light, it was springtime; the grass was green, you
remember, in the feeding of the five thousand. So it got dark…maybe six
o’clock, let’s say seven o’clock…they probably got into the boat roughly about
that time. They’d been on this lake for maybe eight hours, maybe nine hours.
Normally you could cross from one side to the other in under six hours. They’re
still only in the middle of the lake. They’re not making any headway. They find
themselves in trouble! They’re straining on the oars, but they’re not making
any headway. They’re running on empty. They’re not making any ground. And do
you note, sometimes, my friends, you get into trouble through no fault of your
own; that even obeying Jesus will sometimes get you into trouble. The disciples
find themselves in trouble. They find themselves at the mercy of winds and
waves. They find themselves in a storm, and all because they did exactly what
Jesus told them to do.

Don’t be surprised, my friends, don’t be surprised
if you follow Jesus and you heed His word, and you pray prayers like, “I want to
be closer to You, Lord; I want to be a better disciple; I want to be more useful
for You.” Don’t be surprised if that means a storm is coming. Don’t whine when
the storm comes. Don’t complain when the storm comes, because here were these
dear disciples, and in obeying Jesus they found themselves in a storm. Don’t be
surprised, my friends, if you find yourselves in trouble tonight. You’ve come
to the prayer meeting to be with God’s people, to be in the house of God, to
make your prayers and petitions known, and you’ve taken part in prayer or you’ve
listened to the prayer of others, but you’re in a storm tonight–in your mind, in
your heart, in your home, in your marriage, in your place of work, with your
children. Don’t be surprised. Here are these disciples, and they find
themselves in trouble.

II. Well, secondly, I want us to
see that they thought–here’s the conclusion that they draw–they thought Jesus
was ignoring them.

Now let’s explore that a little. It’s difficult to
be precise here, but the fact that ‘evening’ is mentioned in verse 47 and
‘fourth watch of the night’ is mentioned in verse 48, we’ve drawn the probable
conclusion that they’ve been in this storm for several hours. For several hours
they’ve been straining at the oars. For several hours, and Jesus has not come
to them. He’s allowed them to pass through this storm for several hours without
doing anything about it.

It’s worse than that. In verse 48 we read that “He
saw them.” He could see them out on the lake. I don’t think we need to
interpret this…it may be, but I don’t think we need to interpret this as the
divine sight of Jesus, but simply the human sight of Jesus. He could see them,
no more and no less. He was on the mountain, there might have been some ambient
light even in the midst of this storm, and every now and then–perhaps there was
a lamp on the storm of some kind, and He could see it out in the middle of the
Sea of Galilee, and He could see they’re in trouble. Jesus can see His
disciples in trouble, but still He doesn’t come.

And then something extraordinary in verse 48: He
comes to them, but then we read this extraordinary statement that “He intended,
He meant, to pass by them.” Isn’t that weird? Now, isn’t that strange? He’s
finally coming! At last, Jesus is coming, not that the disciples recognized
Him, even when He came, but at last He’s coming, but He intends to pass them
by. And do you know…do you know what that draws from us? Do you know the
conclusion that that draws from us? We’re tempted to draw the conclusion that
Jesus really doesn’t care.

Now, maybe you don’t put it as crassly as I’ve just
put it there, but I wonder if deep down you sometimes think that. You’ve been
praying about a certain matter for weeks, maybe months, maybe years. I have
some things on my prayer list that have been there for thirty-five years. I’ll
be absolutely honest with you. There are times when I think Jesus doesn’t
care. There. I’ve said it. I’m ashamed about it. It’s a sin. It’s a
terrible sin. But there are times when providence forces me into a position to
draw out that false conclusion, that Jesus just doesn’t care. And sometimes He
seems to taunt you; He seems to give the sign that He’s about to answer your
prayer, and then take it away again. But He comes, He actually comes towards
these disciples, but He intends to pass them by….like a….oh, I know you
don’t like cats here, but I love cats! Like a cat. You know how a cat will
play with something…with a half-dead mouse? You know, it will just poke it.
Just try to make it move a little more, and then put its paw on it. As if God is
playing games, Jesus is playing games here with the disciples. What’s going on?

Oh! He’s testing them. That’s what’s going on. How
wrong we can be in interpreting providence. How terribly wrong we can be. Where
is Jesus, anyway? Where’s He been all this time? He’s been up the mountain,
praying. Now, understand, friends, just how astonishing a thing that is: that
the Son of God, the second person of the Trinity; the divine Messiah; the Lord
incarnate is praying. He’s beseeching His heavenly Father. He’s bringing His
petitions before His heavenly Father. He’s “found in a low condition,” as our
Shorter Catechism describes the incarnation of Jesus, and He needs the
help of His Father. He needs the filling of the Holy Spirit so that He can be
enabled to fulfill the task of being the covenant Mediator. And no doubt,
although the text doesn’t tell us, but no doubt part of His prayers were on
behalf of these disciples. I can’t imagine but that He wasn’t praying for these
disciples. He would look out to them on the sea, and He’d say, ‘Heavenly
Father, just look after them for Me. Take care of them for Me. Make sure none
of them drops down into the sea, or drowns. It’s OK for them to get wet; yes,
let the wind blow in their face, and yes, rock the boat a little bit, make them
feel a little queasy because I need to test them, I need to teach them
something. But take care of them. Make sure that not one of them perishes.’

Do you know that’s how Jesus prays for you all the
time? That “we have a Great High Priest who sits at the right hand of God who
ever lives to intercede for us,” the Book of Hebrews says? And that’s what He’s
doing for you right now. He’s interceding for you, my friend. He’s bringing you
by name–by name–and He’s bringing you before His Father’s throne and He’s
interceding on your behalf. That’s where Jesus was. You see, the disciples were
drawing the conclusion that Jesus’ absence meant He wasn’t doing anything. But
He was interceding with His heavenly Father on their behalf.

You see, “their hearts,” the text says in verse 52,
“were hardened.” They’d just–oh, my friends, get it!–they had just seen Jesus
feed the five thousand, but they hadn’t drawn the right conclusions! They didn’t
get it. How slow they were to get it! You know, sometimes we think that if
Jesus were to do some miraculous thing our lives would be altogether changed in
an instant. Don’t believe it for one minute. Don’t you believe it for one
minute. They had witnessed an astonishing miracle, but their hearts were still
hardened. They needed to learn a lesson. You know, I just wonder…the text
doesn’t say so, but I just wonder if the disciples were beginning to think,
‘Maybe that feeding of the five thousand had something to do with me. You know,
maybe there is something special about me after all.’ And within a few hours
they’re at the mercy of a storm and crying out for their lives, and Jesus is
saying, ‘You know what? You need to learn apart from Me, you can do nothing.
Apart from Me, you can do nothing.’

III. Well, there’s a third
thing I want us to see, and that is that in their weakness they experienced
Jesus’ tender care.

Let’s see a couple of things here. First
of all, He walks on the water
. You know, at the end of the day,
that’s not the biggest thing in this story. We tend to focus on that, you know,
and the physicist in me wants to try and explain exactly what happened. But you
know, that’s not the biggest thing in this story. He walks on the water. Do
you know that the ancient Egyptian hieroglyphic for the word “impossible” was
two feet of water, because you can’t walk on two feet of water? What’s
happening? It’s a demonstration; it’s a revelation of His glory. It’s a
demonstration that even the molecules of water must hold up the feet of their
sovereign Lord. It’s a demonstration of His transcendent glory, that the King
of Kings is in their midst.

Notice again that He intends to pass them by.
Now, we’ve seen how odd that may appear, but we need to try and explain why
He intended to pass them by. And of course, if you know your Old Testament, you
are already picking up the allusion to the fact that when God revealed His glory
to Moses on Mt. Sinai in Exodus 33, or to Elijah on Mt. Horeb in that wonderful
incident when He wasn’t in the storm, and He wasn’t in the fires (the choir was
reminding us on Sunday morning), but He was in the still, small voice. But you
know, in both passages we read that God passed them by, that as God’s glory
passed it was as though He was passing them by. And Mark, I think, is
deliberately drawing the allusion that when Jesus is walking on the water
towards these disciples, He’s appearing to them in the very form that God had
appeared to Moses on Mt. Sinai, and to Elijah on Mt. Horeb. This is the Lord,
the Lord of glory. This is Jehovah Jesus. This is Yahweh Jesus walking on the
Sea of Galilee. And to confirm it, He says, “It is I.” And that has so many
allusions to the divine name in the Old Testament, the name that God gave to
Moses: “I Am that I Am.” And then it was shortened to “I Am”, and it sounds
like the word Yahweh, or Jehovah. And Jesus is giving to them a revelation of
His glory, a glimpse of His greatness; of the transcendent Lord that He truly
is. And it moved them greatly.

And Jesus gets into the boat now. Do you
notice….oh! I wish we had time to draw this out! Jesus didn’t stop the storm
and then walk on the water, He walked through the storm and got into the boat
when the storm was still raging, and only then did the storm cease. Do you see
what that says to you? That Jesus actually draws near to you in the midst of
your trouble and identifies Himself with that trouble? And the disciples are
astonished! At first they think they’ve seen a ghost, but then they’re
astonished. And it’s that word that the gospels, so many on so many occasions,
use to describe the sort of goose-pimply effect of being in the presence of the
transcendent Lord, and it sends shivers down your spine.

And those beautiful words that Jesus says to the
disciples: “Take courage…and be not afraid.” Take courage and be not afraid.
“Fear not, I am with you… Do not anxiously look about you, for I am your God.
I will strengthen you; surely I will help you, I will uphold you with My
righteous right hand…Let not your hearts be troubled; ye believe in God,
believe also in Me,” Jesus said. My friend, is that the word you need tonight
in the midst of your trouble and trial and difficulty? The reassuring words of
your sovereign Savior who loves you and cares for you, and promises in covenant
blood to protect you from all of your foes: Do not be afraid. Do not be afraid,
for “I am with you always, even to the end of the age.”

May God bless His word to us, for His name’s sake.
Let’s stand and pray, and receive the Lord’s benediction.

Father, we thank You for Your word, and
especially we thank You for this wonderful glimpse of our risen Lord and Savior,
Jesus Christ, and His love and care for His disciples, and for us, too. Receive
our thanks, and write it upon our hearts for Jesus’ sake. Amen.

May grace, mercy and peace be with you all.

© 2019 First Presbyterian Church.

This transcribed message has been lightly edited and formatted for the Web site. No attempt has been made, however, to alter the basic extemporaneous delivery style, or to produce a grammatically accurate, publication-ready manuscript conforming to an established style template.

Should there be questions regarding grammar or theological content, the reader should presume any website error to be with the webmaster/transcriber/editor rather than with the original speaker. For full copyright, reproduction and permission information, please visit the First Presbyterian Church Copyright, Reproduction & Permission statement.