Joshua: Ouch!

Sermon by on March 10, 2002

Joshua 5:1-11

Joshua 5:1-12
Dr. Derek Thomas

Imagine that you were some great military leader preparing your men for
battle in the hours that follow. How would you go about it? Stonewall Jackson
prayed with his men. Henry V, before the battle of Agincourt, walked amongst
them and spoke words of courage, rallying them to “stiffen the sinews and
summon up the blood.” You may remember the great scenes of battle in Braveheart
and how William Wallace prepared his men. Most leaders advise that men who fight
in a battle need a period of rest and refreshment prior to the fight.

Or perhaps, we should think of the preparations of the first (and what was
thought to be the only) battle of the Civil War, Bull Run (or Manassas, as the
confederates called it), as the Union forces advanced from Washington to
Richmond, Virginia and had to pass through Manassas. The Union soldiers (about
35,000 men) were led by Irvin McDowell, a West Point graduate and veteran of the
Mexican War, who turned out to be less able than the claims made about him, and
General P.G.T. Beauregard, who commanded the 22,000 Confederate soldiers. It was
in this battle that Stonewall Jackson was to emerge as a hero.

The battle had been in preparation for weeks, perhaps months. Folk came down
from Washington with picnic baskets in order to watch it. Many thought the
“war” would be won or lost by the outcome of this one battle.

How did these men prepare. Most of them were 90-day volunteers, who were
growing fed up with waiting around in the heat of summer. They went over the
plans, the strategy of how they saw the battle, looking at maps, making sure
that lines of command were working well. They would write letters to loved ones,
pray, rest.

The whole story that now unfolds is in many ways an astonishing one, not
least because of the way this conquest of the land of Canaan is engaged in, for
what happens here is, from a purely militaristic way, suicidal. It is hard to
imagine anything better calculated to incapacitate an entire army of men than
this act of circumcision that takes place on the western side of the river
Jordan. Everything about it is designed to point out to us that God’s ways are
not our ways. It is designed to emphasize the Lord’s sovereignty in this
conquest; that the battle is to be fought, not as an example of ethnic group
dispossessing another of their land, as happens again and again. Rather, what is
taking place here is in many ways, a holy jihad, a conquest based upon
divine assessment that the Canaanites had used up their allowance of God’s
patience. That, as Amos was to let Israel know centuries latter, for three
transgressions and for four God comes and visits with divine punishment.

There is a limit to divine patience, and the Canaanites had reached it: the
iniquity of “the Amorites was full” and the cup of God’s wrath was
to be poured out, using the Israelites as the instruments of his holy jihad
against Canaan. But they dare not enter this battle in any other way but in the
strength of the Lord Almighty. They were never to forget that they were the
covenant people of God.

Three features of that relationship are now emphasized in this chapter as it
describes for us the preparation of the people of God for battle.

First, is the demoralization of the enemies of God (v.1).
Second, is the consecration of the army of God (vv.2-10)
Third, is the provision for the people of God (vv.11-12)

I. First, is the demoralization of the enemies of God (v.

In many ways, what is told us
here is for our benefit, rather than for the benefit of the men now preparing
for battle. This is to some extent an editorial comment made for us to
appreciate what is going to happen in the next few chapters. God’s
intervention in the form of the drying up of the river Jordan had caused the
hearts of the enemies of God to melt. They lost heart. Their morale was shaken
by this intervention.

It is doubtful if the men on the western shores of the Jordan near Jericho
were even aware of the intentions of the Amorite and Canaanite kings. This part
of the story is written after the fact in order to tell us, as we now read the
tale, that God was, in fact, going before them, opening up a way for these
untrained and amateur soldiers to conquer the land of Canaan. God was blazing a
trail for them to follow. What is happening here is a glimpse that the conquest
of Canaan is something God brings about, that the promise that God had made
is going to be fulfilled
. I am sure that these Israelite men were surprised
as to how little resistance they met as they crossed over the Jordan, that they
were not met with anything like the forces that greeted, say the British and
Americans whenever they crossed over from Kuwait into Iraq during the war that
followed the Iraqi occupation of Kuwait in 1990.

There was in fact nothing! Not a single soldier met them. No hostilities
blocked they path toward Jericho. Why not? Because the Lord had gone before them
and had melted the hearts of the opposition. What we have here is something of
the signal nature of what will be the explanation for this conquest in its
entirety: God gave them victory. The battle was not theirs, but the Lord’s.
They could no more crow over their military exploits and victories than we
can boast about our salvation. It is God’s doing.

But this is only a prelude to a more important part of the story:

II. Second, is the consecration of the people of God (vv.

It’s hard to exaggerate the
shock of verse 2, to Joshua as military commander, and to the men who now have
to undergo this procedure. “Make flint knives and circumcise the Israelites
again (Hebrew: a second time). The practice had fallen into
neglect–all those 40 years and younger had not been circumcised (vv.4-7).
There had been a hint of it in the wilderness period in the incident with Moses
and his wife Zipporah and their son (Exod. 4).

And the effect of this is related in verse 8: they needed time to heal!

Now, do I need to spell this out? I hope not! My British reserve is shouting
to me, “Stop!” These were grown men, not little children. The entire
procedure would incapacitate them for several days (to say the least!). This was
militarily disastrous. It placed them wide open to attack. Had this happened on
the eastern side of the Jordan it might have been a little better; at
least then they would have the shelter of the Jordan in full flood to protect
them from surprise attacks by the Canaanites. But here, on the western side
it makes no sense at all. It is suicidal and foolish.

So why did God tell Joshua to do this?

First: Circumcision was a sign and seal of the covenant
of grace. I put it like that because it’s often suggested by some
that circumcision was first and foremost a badge of national identity. It’s
what marked out the Jews from other races in the Middle East. Now, in fact, this
is quite untrue. The Egyptians, for example, practiced circumcision. But why
would anyone want to make this point at all?

What is the significance of saying, circumcision is what marks out your
Jewishness? Partly, because there are some who want to downplay its spiritual
importance and that because of the implications it has for its relationship to
baptism. In Colossians 2:11 and again in Romans 4:11-12, Paul makes the point
that circumcision and baptism point to the very same spiritual reality: they are
both of them signs and seals of God’s covenant of grace with His people. The
point being that since, in the case of circumcision, the sign and seal was
applied to children (specifically, male children eight days of age), baptism as
the bloodless sacrament of the new covenant ought also to be applied to

You have to go back to Genesis 17:10: “This is My covenant… every male
among you shall be circumcised…Verse 11: “it shall be a sign of the
covenant between you and Me…”

The rite of circumcision pointed to and confirmed the promise that God had
made, a promise that included the conquest of the land of Canaan, as well as the
promise that God had made to be their God (Gen. 17:8). It was a sign of
something physical and temporary, the land of Canaan, but also of something
eternal and enduring–their relationship with God and the enduring ‘land’
of the Canaan which is to come of the eternal city of the New Jerusalem, the new
heavens and the new earth. Circumcision pointed to their union and communion
with God as much as it did to the land of Canaan as God’s gift to them. As
such, Genesis 17 is very clear indeed: “Any uncircumcised male who is not
circumcised… shall be cut off from his people; he has broken My covenant”
(Gen. 17:14).

Do you see why Paul calls it, “a seal of the righteousness that Abraham
had by faith while he was yet uncircumcised” (Rom 4:11). It is not a seal
of Abraham’s response, but to something God gave him and which Abraham
received by faith.
It was a sign and seal of the gospel. Of
justification by faith, of the forgiveness of sins, of adoption, of union and
communion with Christ, of perseverance and holiness, of the promise of eternal

Circumcision pointed to their identity as the Lord’s covenant people. That
God had made promises to them and they had entered into that covenant. Failure
to be circumcised indicated that they were going it alone, they were attempting
to occupy the land in their strength.

Circumcision is one of a number of covenant signs and symbols:

Moses–Sabbath Day (Exodus 31) and the Passover
David–throne (Psalm 89)
New Covenant–Baptism and the Lord’s Supper

What is at stake is the promise that God has made (Josh 5:6).

Martin Luther, whenever he was tempted to sin by Satan, would refer to his
baptism, saying, “Baptismus sum“–I am a baptized man! It wasn’t
that Luther believed in some sacramental power inherent within baptism itself.
Indeed, Luther violently repudiated any notion of an ex opera operato
power of the sacraments. But he did believe that baptism pointed to certain
promises and assurances that God had made to “whosoever believed in Jesus
Christ” as their Savior.

In the same way, these men of Israel must swear their allegiance to be the
Lord’s people who are depending utterly upon the Lord for salvation and
deliverance by acceding to the rite of circumcision. In that way, it was a
sacrament of consecration. In it they were set apart to be the Lord’s people,
to live out and out for Him.

Latin word sacramentum —not a particularly felicitous term (it is
better to look at Bible words). It points to the oath of allegiance that a Roman
soldier might have given, the pledge if you like. And it is to this that The
Westminster Confession
points in 17:i (printed on your evening worship
guides) whenever it says of sacraments that they “put a visible difference
between those that belong unto the church and the rest of the world.” These
soldiers must conquer Jericho by means that distinguish themselves as the Lord’s
people. As soldiers, they must be seen to be the Lord’s soldiers! How
astonishing that is! That “holiness unto the Lord” is to mark their
fighting! There is nothing unsacred! Nothing! We are always the Lord’s people
no matter what we are doing.

Second: circumcision
was necessary for another reason: so that they might celebrate the other
sacrament, Passover
(v.10). There had been no celebration of the
Passover for 39 years! The last time they had partaken of the Passover was at
Mount Sinai. The sacrament which reminded them of how God had brought Egypt to
its knees and how He had delivered them across the Red Sea, as a prelude to what
now lies before them–the occupation of Canaan. Thirty-nine years of wanderings
have passed, due to their sin and unbelief, but now they must remember again.
The God of battles is with them.

God had delivered them from Egypt through sacrifice and substitution and
satisfaction of a lamb’s life offered in their place. Just as we now do, as
those baptized in Jesus’ name, in whom the realties of what baptism has
promised have been evidenced in a life of faith, love and obedience, and we
drink of his blood and eat his flesh, symbolized in wine and bread at the Lord’s
Table. There we remind ourselves of what Jesus has done, is doing, and will yet
do. We eat and drink in His presence, so that nourished by His Spirit we pledge
ourselves to be the Lord’s and wait, ‘till He comes’ for the new heavens
and the new earth. As we traverse this interval between the two ‘comings’ of
Jesus, in this age when the age to come has already broken through, and our
lives are hid with Christ in God, we find daily strength to cope with life’s
hardships, “the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune” by fellowship
with Christ who is our Prophet, Priest and King.

Every step we make, we make because He has gone before us. His life has been
poured out in death, His soul has borne the anger of a just God against sin, His
resurrection has pronounced the victory.

“Do this in remembrance of me” Jesus said whenever He inaugurated
the Lord’s Supper. It is interesting that one of the things Moses had told the
people on the plains of Moab, just before he died and before they set out to
cross the Jordan under the leadership of Joshua, was the instruction “Be
careful that you do not forget the Lord your God” (Deut. 8:11). And a
solemn warning was added: “If you ever forget the LORD your God and follow
other gods and worship and bow down to them, I testify against you today that
you will surely be destroyed” (Deut. 8:19).

Every fall in Britain, there is a ceremony held on a Sunday morning at 11.00
am at local cenotaphs or war memorials. Poppy wreaths are laid in memory of the
fallen who died on the Fields of Flanders where, it is said, poppies were in
abundance. It is a ceremony that remembers the fallen of all wars, but
especially of the Great War and the Second World War, but also more recent
deaths. It is now a part of the tradition that a two minute silence be held,
when folk stand to attention and at the end of which the words of the poet,
Laurence Binyon, are recited from a poem entitled For the Fallen which he
wrote in 1914.

They shall grow not old, as we that are left grow old:
Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn.
At the going down of the sun and in the morning
We will remember them.

The problem is that my generation, and those of my children were not alive in
either of these wars, and the memory of them does not exist. Each year, the
number who attend these memorials get fewer and fewer and there are voices which
call for its end. But there are those, and I am one of them, that thinks that we
should never forget what men did for the sake of liberty and freedom, the
millions who lost their lives in battle. It is all too easy to forget the cost
of freedom and in forgetting, repeat the errors of the past.

In just the same way, we can forget what God has done for us in Jesus Christ.

King of my life I crown Thee now,
Thine shall the glory be;
Lest I forget Thy thorn-crowned brow,
Lead me to Calvary.

Lest I forget Gethsemane,
Lest I forget Thy agony,
Lest I forget Thy love for me,
Lead me to Calvary.

III. Third, is the provision for the people of God (vv.

I don’t want to say much about
this except that this is a beautiful statement of how life in this world is
meant to be lived.

They are taught to live by partaking of the produce of ordinary providence
rather than that of miraculous providence. It was time for them to stop
depending on miracles and divine intervention in the course of things. They must
work for their food and eat the produce of their labors asking the Lord to bless

Unleavened bread and roasted grain may not sound like much, but it’s a
token of what is to come. God has brought them into the land and they can now
eat from its produce. No longer will they eat manna to be gathered on a daily
basis (except for the Sabbath). God has kept His word. He will provide for them.
His word has come true. They have pledged themselves to be His, and He is
keeping his word of promise to them. Not a single day had gone by when the manna
did not arrive (except the Sabbath day–there was double provision on the eve
of the Sabbath for that necessity). Not a single day! Because that is what the
faithfulness of God is like. Not a single day will He neglect our welfare and
our good.

What is it saying to us? Simply this: that God will take of us till we reach
the Canaan which is to come. You think I am spiritualizing this passage? Then go
home and read Hebrews 4 and the Sabbath rest which is yet to come which Joshua
was not able to give us! Every step of the way, His faithfulness will follow us.

Every step!

© 2019 First Presbyterian Church.

This transcribed message has been lightly edited and formatted for the Web site. No attempt has been made, however, to alter the basic extemporaneous delivery style, or to produce a grammatically accurate, publication-ready manuscript conforming to an established style template.

Should there be questions regarding grammar or theological content, the reader should presume any website error to be with the webmaster/transcriber/editor rather than with the original speaker. For full copyright, reproduction and permission information, please visit the First Presbyterian Church Copyright, Reproduction & Permission statement.