The Lord’s Day Evening
October 3, 2010
2 Samuel 4:1-12
“Murder Most Foul!”
Dr. Derek W. H. Thomas
Turn with me to 2 Samuel chapter 4.
2 Samuel chapter 4 — we’re going to read about
Ish-bosheth, the only
remaining son of Saul who’s been put on the throne in the northern kingdom, but
as we shall see, his reign is short lived.
Before we read the passage together, let’s look to God in prayer.
Father, we thank You for the
Scriptures. They are able to make us
wise unto salvation through faith which is in Jesus Christ our Lord.
We ask now for Your blessing, the outpouring of Your Spirit.
We pray that we might be enabled to read, mark, learn, and inwardly
digest, and all for Jesus’ sake.
This is God’s holy and inerrant Word:
Saul’s son, heard that Abner had died at Hebron,
his courage failed, and all
was dismayed. Now Saul’s son had two
men who were captains of raiding bands; the name of the one was Baanah, and the
name of the other Rechab, sons of Rimmon a man of Benjamin from Beeroth (for
Beeroth also is counted part of Benjamin; the Beerothites fled to Gittaim and
have been sojourners there to this day).
Jonathan, the son of
Saul, had a son who was crippled in his feet.
He was five years old when the news about Saul and Jonathan came from
Jezreel, and his nurse took him up and fled, and as she fled in her haste, he
fell and became lame. And his name
Now the sons of
Rimmon the Berrothite, Rechab and Baanah, set out, and about the heat of the day
they came to the house of Ish-bosheth as he was taking his noonday rest.
And they came into the midst of the house as if to get wheat, and they
stabbed him in the stomach. Then
Rechab and Baanah his brother escaped.
When they came into the house, as he lay on his bed in his bedroom, they
struck him and put him to death and beheaded him.
They took his head and went by the way of Arabah all night, and brought
the head of Ish-bosheth to David at
they said to the king, ‘Here is the head of Ish-bosheth, the son of Saul, your
enemy, who sought your life. The
Lord has avenged my lord the king this day on Saul and on his offspring.’
But David answered Rachab and Baanah his brother, the sons of Rimmon the
Beerothite, ‘As the Lord lives, who has redeemed my life out of every adversity,
when one told me, ‘Behold, Saul is dead,’ and thought he was bringing good news,
I seized him and killed him at Ziklag, which was the reward I gave him for his
news. How much more, when wicked men
have killed a righteous man in his own house on his bed, shall I not now require
his blood at your hand and destroy you from the earth?’
And David commanded his young men, and they killed them and cut off their
hands and feet and hanged them beside the pool at
But they took the head of Ish-bosheth and buried it in the tomb of Abner
Well, thus far, God’s holy, inerrant Word.
What a pleasant story!
You know, as I was thinking about this passage — and you’ve got to believe I was
thinking about it most of this week — having the heebie-jeebies when I saw the
first and second grade choirs singing in the evening service.
Where is Jesus in this text?
Indeed, where is Jesus in this text?
And I think that perhaps this is another occasion where the better question
might be, “What is Jesus teaching us in this text?”
Let us not forget this is part of
This is part of the fulfillment of a promise that the Son of David will
one day come and rule and reign.
Didn’t I hear the little angels sing, “Jesus shall reign” just a few minutes
ago? Well, the lineage of that Jesus
lies here in this gruesome, awful tale.
I want to look at it tonight from two perspectives, from, first of all,
the perspective of the north — that is, Ish-bosheth and
Israel — and secondly from the perspective of David at
in the south.
Ish-bosheth — I have to say I was reminded, just briefly, of Thomas Gray’s poem
that I once was forced to learn in school, “Elegy in a Country Churchyard” — not
one of your favorite poems, I’m sure.
It’s about a man contemplating as the sun goes down.
He’s in a country churchyard and he’s contemplating the graves and the
names of those written on the graves and they are nobodies.
Who knows who they are?
Nobody remembers them. They’re not
some of the great and notorious people of history; they’re just forgotten.
And that’s Ish-bosheth. He’s
been made king, do you see, by Abner.
Saul and his three sons were killed on
MountGilboa fighting the
Philistines and after probably a period of about three years, Abner, the general
of Saul’s army in the north, put the remaining son, Ish-bosheth, on the throne.
He made him king and then he went and unmade him king.
Ish-bosheth had the temerity to accuse Abner of a little incident with a
certain concubine, and Abner, in a fit of rage, told Ish-bosheth — you remember
a couple of weeks ago? We were
looking at the previous passages.
Abner told Ish-bosheth that just as he had made him king, so surely he would
unmake him king.
You remember Abner had inadvertently killed Joab’s brother, Asahel with a blunt
end of his spear. It was probably
accidental. It wasn’t murder with
intent. But Joab, Asahel’s brother —
Joab is one of the chief men in David’s camp — had been angry with David for
receiving Abner, and remember, had asked Abner to come to the city gates of Hebron — a protected city, a city of refuge, a
city where anyone fleeing from his avenger could get justice.
And Joab had killed him. So
Saul is dead, Jonathan is dead, his two brothers are dead, Abner is now dead,
and we read in the first verse of chapter 4 — “When Ish-bosheth, Saul’s son,
heard that Abner had died at Hebron, his courage failed
him.” Literally, his hands dropped.
His courage failed him. He
never wanted to be king. He was
ill-equipped to be king. He was
never meant to be king. He didn’t
want the job. He couldn’t do the
Sometimes life isn’t fair. Sometimes
life isn’t fair. He’s a puppet-king.
He’s put in power by others.
He doesn’t want to be in this situation and life isn’t fair.
He’s not Oliver Cromwell.
He’s Richard Cromwell. Richard
Cromwell, Oliver Cromwell’s son, lasted nine months.
He was so bad, England went
back to monarchy. His courage failed
him. You feel sorry for
Ish-bosheth. You know, you wouldn’t
even know about him if he wasn’t here in this chapter.
You know, nobody’s saying here tonight, “You know, you’re saying, I want
to be like David.” Some of you
military types are enamored of the figures of Joab and Abner.
You know, they’re men.
They’re real men. They’re soldiers,
anywhere there was to fight. But no
one’s saying here, “I want to be Ish-bosheth.
You know I really want to be Ish-bosheth.”
No, you feel sorry for him.
He’s the wrong man in the wrong place at the wrong time.
He’s weak. He’s weak.
He’s a patsy. He’s a man
under the control of others.
And now two would-be young pretenders, who can probably read what’s going to
happen — the downfall of the northern kingdom — thinking that they might
ingratiate themselves to David and have plum government jobs with a pension and
health benefits, they kill him. Oh,
brave young men, they kill him while he’s asleep in his bed, like Duncan in
Macbeth, only not quite so dramatic.
Life isn’t fair. You know,
he’s in the wrong place at the wrong time, and he’s killed.
He’s murdered – murder most foul.
You know, there’s something you want to say when you read this.
You know, whatever Ish-bosheth was, he didn’t deserve that.
You know, he didn’t deserve that.
He’s an innocent victim of ambitious and unscrupulous men.
Can you identify a little with him, perhaps?
Life isn’t fair. Your husband
is cheating on you. You don’t deserve that.
Life isn’t fair. You have
ambitions for your children — some of you have too many ambitions for your
children; ambitions that are not good for you or them.
But perhaps for some of you, you look at your children and you think,
“Why can’t I have other people’s children?”
Life isn’t fair. Some of
you know all too well what it is to be stabbed in the back by someone at work
who’s climbing the corporate ladder and you thought they were friends.
And when the moment of opportunity came, they stabbed you in the back.
Life isn’t fair. “I’m doing
my job. I’m trying my best.”
That’s what I think about Ish-bosheth and life isn’t fair.
There’s no one, there’s no one here tonight who’s saying, “I want to be
Ish-bosheth.” He’s dead.
He’s murdered. He’s beheaded
by two young pretenders who take his head down to
Now, let’s move away from that grizzly story.
Let’s go south. Let’s go to
David’s camp —probably a two day journey.
Rechab and Baanah — now notice in verse 8, notice that when you think you
want something you can put theological language to justify it.
So they come to David and they’re holding the head of Ish-bosheth, two
days now, decomposing in their hands — “The son of Saul, your enemy, who sought
your life. The Lord” – now notice
this theological, heavyweight explanation of what it is that they’ve done —“The
Lord has avenged my lord the king this day on Saul and on his offspring.”
Well, let’s think about that for a minute, this piece of theological
self-justification — what they were doing was avenging the attempts of Saul to
kill David. I mean, hadn’t God
promised that David would rule over a
Yes, He had. Hadn’t God
promised that David would rule at the downfall of Saul’s kingdom?
Yes, He had.
So, doesn’t the end justify the
I mean, this brought about the end of Saul’s kingdom.
There was only one other left, Mephibosheth, and he was a cripple.
His nurse had dropped him, fleeing when she heard of the death of his
father, Jonathan. The northern
kingdom is over. David is now going
to be the united king of a united north and south, and they had just
accomplished the wiping out of every obstacle in that path to glory.
Doesn’t the end justify the means?
It’s called in ethics, consequentialism.
I was in Atlanta airport, as I often am, a couple of weeks ago, a couple of
Saturdays ago, and I began a conversation with a lady — we had just flow to
Meridian and then flown back again; some mechanical problem which was never
explained — and I was explaining to her what Delta actually meant:
Delays Expected When Leaving Through Atlanta.
(laughter) This lady traveled
the world. She went all over the
world — something to do with heart transplant technology.
It was way above my understanding.
And she began to talk about stem-cell research and what great advances
were being made in China. I
listened with great interest. The
end justifying the means. At what
cost was this great expertise in stem-cell research being done?
At the death of thousands, no, hundreds of thousands, no, millions of
unborn children. Does the end
justify the means?
That’s what these two are saying to David.
“Look, we’ve advanced the
It was an opportunity. It was
a providence. The door was open and
God had given the promise. We’re
helping you, David!” Except that
David didn’t see it that way. They
obviously did not know what David had done to the Amalekite, you remember, who
came running to David in chapter 1 of 2 Samuel with the king Saul’s crown and
amulets, suggesting to David that he in fact had killed him for David.
And what had David done to the Amalekite?
He told his young men to kill him because he had killed, at least he had
confessed to have killed, the Lord’s anointed.
It was justice.
Now, David has his young men take these two young want-a-be pretenders, their
hands and feet are severed, and they’re hung like an advertisement from a
billboard on I-55, only it’s Hebron.
And, you might say, “Praise God we live in more enlightened times.”
And maybe you’re right.
But you see, the question I want to ask tonight is this — what kind of kingdom,
what kind of kingdom does David want to bring in?
What kind of kingdom will David
rule over? Will it be a kingdom
governed by the ethics of consequentialism, that the end justifies the means?
It will be a kingdom governed by
justice and righteousness.
These two young men that committed murder, murder most foul, the murder
of a king while he’s sleeping in his bed — this was a murder with intent.
They got what the Law, what the Torah had prescribed.
That’s all that happened to them.
You see, let me put it this way tonight.
If we have, if we have a low view of justice, if we have a low view of
justice, we read this passage and we “tut-tut” at it.
How dare David do this? What
kind of uncivilized society is this, to put murderers to death?
What kind of uncivilized society is that?
It’s a society governed by the Law of Moses, that’s what it is.
We are so far away from that we find it almost disgusting.
But there is nothing here in what David did that was anything other than
what was right and prescribed in the Law of Moses.
You see, let me put it this way — if we
have a low view of justice, we’ll have a low view of the Gospel.
And you say, you say, “How can that possibly be?”
Because, my friends, the Gospel is actually built on the foundations of
Do you remember when Paul says in Romans 8, “He that did not spare His own Son”?
He didn’t spare Him. The
innocent, perfect, Lamb of God, He didn’t spare Him.
You see, here’s the thing — Jesus had asked to be spared.
In the Garden of Gethsemane He had said to His Father,
“Father, if it is possible, if there’s some other way.”
You can almost eavesdrop the answer.
The Father says, the Father says to His Son, “Son, we promised.
We made a promise. We made a
covenant in eternity. Remember?
We made a covenant and You would be the Mediator of that covenant.
It’s a promise. Son, we can’t
go back on our word. It’s a matter
of justice. It’s a matter of
integrity. It’s a matter of
David is bringing in the kingdom that is built on the foundations of
righteousness and justice, not the end justifying the means.
Now David will forget, because power corrupts and absolute power corrupts
absolutely, for human beings anyway.
Within a few chapters we’ll see David behave like a Chicago gangster thug, sending murderers to
battlefield to ensure that the husband of the wife that he has now impregnated
be killed. But at least here, at
least here in chapter 4, David’s concern is for a kingdom that is built on the
foundation of justice and righteousness.
Do you remember what Paul says in the opening chapter of Romans when he says,
“I’m not ashamed of the Gospel. I’m
not ashamed of the Gospel because therein is the forgiveness of God revealed”?
No, that’s not what it says.
You might think that’s what it says, you might have thought in a quiz that’s
what Paul said — that’s why he’s not ashamed of the Gospel because in the Gospel
there is forgiveness — but that’s not what he said.
“I’m not ashamed of the Gospel because the righteousness of God is
revealed in it.”
You know, when Luther read that, he said at one point, as he tells us in his
introduction to his commentary on Romans, he says that when he first read that
and he thought about it, he hated God and he hated God’s righteousness.
How can the righteousness, the justice of God, be something in which
he rejoice? Because as he came
on to see, that righteousness is revealed from faith to faith.
It’s a righteousness that we receive by faith alone, in Jesus Christ alone.
“He was made sin for us who knew no sin that we might be reckoned the
righteousness of God in Him.” I’m
not ashamed of the Gospel because it’s about righteousness.
It’s about being right with God.
It’s about integrity. But
it’s a rightness and an integrity that I received by faith in Jesus Christ.
the Gospel my friends.
That’s what’s at the heart of the Gospel.
David is introducing a kingdom. He’s
ushering in a kingdom. He’s on the
very threshold of that kingdom. Now
in the next few chapters, he’s going to be crowned in a great pomp and ceremony
in Jerusalem and a covenant,
a covenant in chapter 7 is going to be established.
That’s one of the most important things in all the Old Testament.
And it’s going to point to the coming of Jesus.
Now David isn’t Jesus.
He sometimes acts as a type of Jesus, but
David could never save us.
Only Jesus can save
us. Only the righteous one.
Only the just one. Only the
So right here, in a chapter that is — you know it’s like a murder mystery that I
think goes on TV tonight, on public television on I think one of those programs
where it’s all about murder and there’s usually two or three of them — and
you’ve got it here. Three people are
dead in this small chapter. And God
in His indescribable, inexplicable providence, is working out His purposes.
“God moves in a mysterious way, His
wonders to perform;
He plants His footsteps in the sea and rides upon the storm.
Deep in unfathomable mines of never-failing skill,
He treasures up His bright designs and works His sovereign will.
Blind unbelief is sure to err and scan His work in vain.
God is His own interpreter and He will make it plain.”
Yes, this sad, awful, wretched story is
one of the pillars that leads eventually to the edifice, which is Christ
Himself, the only true and just and righteous King.
May God bless His Word to us. Let’s
Father, we stand amazed as we
read these Old Testament stories and as we are traveling through the books of
Samuel, sometimes we feel glad that we’re not there, that we live in what we
sometimes fool ourselves into thinking are more enlightened times.
We thank You, O Lord, for the ways in which these passages beg for us to
call out for a righteous King and how we have seen that righteous King in the
face of Jesus Christ, our Lord and our Savior.
How sweet the name of Jesus sounds in a believer’s ear, calms his
sorrows, heals his wounds, and drives away his fear.
We thank You that for those who feel like Ish-bosheth tonight, victims of
circumstances that outwardly appear to be unfair, that only in Jesus Christ can
peace and resolution and contentment come.
So to those of our brothers and sisters tonight, who perhaps secretly and
quietly have identified with Ish-bosheth, may that peace that passes all
understanding that garrisons the heart be theirs tonight.
For Jesus’ sake we ask it.
Please stand and receive the Lord’s benediction.
Grace, mercy, and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ, be with
© 2019 First Presbyterian Church.
This transcribed message has been lightly edited and formatted for the Web site. No attempt has been made, however, to alter the basic extemporaneous delivery style, or to produce a grammatically accurate, publication-ready manuscript conforming to an established style template.
Should there be questions regarding grammar or theological content, the reader should presume any website error to be with the webmaster/transcriber/editor rather than with the original speaker. For full copyright, reproduction and permission information, please visit the First Presbyterian Church Copyright, Reproduction & Permission statement.
To view recordings of our entire services, visit our Facebook page.